'My Best Friend's Girl' review

A romantic comedy that'll make you want to swear off romance

By Geoff Berkshire

Metromix
September 19, 2008

 
Critic's Rating:
1

'My Best Friend's Girl' review
(Credit: Lionsgate)
Photos:
Dane Cook as Tank, Mini Anden as Lizzy, Jason Biggs as Dustin in "My Best Friend's Girl." Jason Biggs as Dustin and Lizzy Caplan as Ami in "My Best Friend's Girl." Director Howard Deutch with Kate Hudson and Dane Cook on the set of "My Best Friend's Girl." Kate Hudson as Alexis and Lizzy Caplan as Ami in "My Best Friend's Girl."
My Best Friend's Girl
Running time:
103 minutes
Rated:
R
Cast:
Dane Cook -
Tank
Kate Hudson -
Alexis
Jason Biggs -
Dustin
Alec Baldwin -
Prof. Turner
Lizzy Caplan -
Ami
Director:
Howard Deutch
Official Movie Web Site:
http://www.mybestfriendsgirlmovie.com/
Movie Trailer:
Overall User Rating:
3 1/2 (6 ratings)
Be the first to review

Tank (Dane Cook) is so good at being a jackass that when guys get dumped they pay him to take their exes out on dates terrible enough to make the girls go running back to their former boyfriends. Tank reluctantly agrees to work his “magic” on Alexis (Kate Hudson), the dream girl of his best friend Dustin (Jason Biggs), but the plan backfires when Alexis decides she’s up for a meaningless fling with a nasty boy. And Tank starts to realize why Dustin finds her so appealing.

Big question: Will the ongoing threat to humanity that is Cook’s movie career ever end?

Skip it: Whoever thought it was a good idea to match an actor as unappealing as Cook with a character that does nothing but make you squirm for 100 minutes was wrong. And why in the name of Mira Sorvino is one-time Oscar nominee Hudson wasting her naturally sunny charm on trash like this? A smarter film might have been able to convincingly peel back the layers of Tank’s self-loathing to make the audience believe he deserves a shot with Alexis. But not this one. It’s a nauseating fraud from start to finish.

Catch it: To see why Alec Baldwin should never, ever leave “30 Rock” or else risk winding up in more insulting “in it for the paycheck” roles like the one he has here as Tank’s lecherous college professor father.

Bottom line: From tacky direction to cardboard characters to “jokes” that confuse cruelty with edgy comedy, the film’s level of awfulness is nothing new for Cook, but Hudson hits a new low. She’s been in plenty of crap before, just never anything this outright vile. The entire uninspired project has the noxious vibes of a star vehicle for a career that’s already stalled, supported by actors on the wrong side of Hollywood’s “It” list. That’s more than unfunny, it’s depressing.

Add a comment

Please log in to comment

SHOWTIME LISTINGS

Movie theaters and showtimes for My Best Friend's Girl in Des Moines.

Narrow search by zipcode:

No Showtimes available

PHOTO GALLERY

Stand-ups on screen

Stand-ups on screen

Wondering why Dane Cook is a movie star? He's...

Movie reviews

Movie reviews

Catch up on recent film reviews you might have missed the first time around.

More on Metromix.com

Ornament-bottom-yellow