Sandwich smackdown

May 15, 2012

Sandwich smackdown

A good sandwich balances a combination of delectable ingredients with delicious bread. A regular microcosm of cuisine that fits in your hands.

We reviewed 16 of the best local sandwiches in eight different categories. No tenderloins. No barbecue. And no burgers allowed. Now it’s up to you to vote for a sandwich to come out on top in our sandwich smackdown bracket.

Winner of the Sandwich Smackdown: Dad's Killer Sandwich

The B&B sandwich killed the competition to come out on top

Gutbuster: The Whole Megillah

There are certain things that should just be done by a man of God: last rites, kosher slaughter, exorcisms. You can apparently add “making an awesome sandwich” to that list, too.

Gutbuster: Dad's Killer Sandwich

Is the name letting us know that it’s a great sandwich, or that dads should update their life insurance policy? Thankfully, the thing most likely to be wiped out is your appetite.

Vegetarian: Spicy four cheese panini

A sandwich that will make you scoff at an ordinary grilled cheese, this multi-cheese creation on focaccia is a delicious mix of coordinating flavors.

Vegetarian: Sweet potato red onion po'boy

The wheat sub roll mixes sweet and savory with grilled sweet potato slices, red onions grilled to salty sweetness, alfalfa sprouts, Maytag blue cheese and cream cheese. This is a sandwich for the hungry vegetarian

International: Beaudelaire Bauru

Cafe Beaudelaire’s Beaudelaire Bauru sandwich is the perfect way to experience a taste of Brazil in the heart of Ames’ Campustown.

International: Bahn mi

Bahn mi, a traditional Vietnamese sub, is an inexpensive treat that includes meat, crunchy veggies and herbs on a toasted baguette

Luna BLT

Luna Bistro and Catering’s BLT is a dressed up version made with La Quercia pancetta, crisply shredded iceberg lettuce and a homemade tomato jam in place of slices of tomato. Luna lightly grills its BLT as well, adding a nice crunch to the bread, and melting the jam slightly so it melds the sandwich together.

Salmon BLT

It’s a beast of a sandwich on a thick, soft, dense bun. Inside, leaves of lettuce are substituted with romaine hearts, which lend a loud crunch to each bite. The tomato is thick and juicy, and the applewood smoked bacon — well, it’s tender, fatty and still dripping with the perfect amount of grease

Deli: Palmer's Club

When you want a solid deli sandwich, you go to Palmer’s. The bustling deli has about any combination of fresh deli meats, cheeses, breads and accoutrements you could ask for. But when you’re in the mood for a big sandwich heaped full of meat, the Palmer’s Club is the answer.

Deli: The Tuesday Special

It’s a loaded sandwich that started as a once-a-week option before a cult following encouraged the staff to sell the sandwich every day. The sandwich starts on a hoagie bun, then roasted turkey and ham are piled on and covered in Baby Swiss cheese. Finally, a homemade Parmesan sauce is heartily drizzled on top, with a sprinkle of fresh herbs. Then, the staff pops the sandwich in a mini oven to warm the meat, soften the hoagie further and melt the Swiss and cheese sauce into a hot, gooey, irresistible sandwich.

Prosciutto panini

It’s thick slices of Iowa-made La Quercia prociutto, stacked between two pieces of ciabatta bread along with fig jam, arugula and Dijon mustard.

Panini: Sarah's Revenge

We don’t know who Sarah is, but we’d kind of like to shake the jerk’s hand that prompted the creation of the lunch spot’s popular sandwich, Sarah’s Revenge.

Italian beef: A Taste of Italy's

For a long time Wednesdays were packed at A Taste of Italy. That’s because Wednesday was the day the Clive shop would sell its Italian beef sandwiches. Thankfully, Taste of Italy is now serving them on a daily basis, making hungry diners happy every day of the week.

Italian beef: Fatty's Italian beef

This is not a sandwich you eat while walking around. A hoagie roll is filled with the Italian beef (and hot and sweet peppers, if you so desire), and then the au jus is poured over it. You need to eat this with a knife and fork, because once the bread soaks up the liquid, it won’t stay together so well in your hands.

Italian sausage: Bottle Cap Burger

A half-pound of Graziano sausage, cooked to perfection. Frankly, if a central Iowa restaurant has an Italian sausage sandwich made without Graziano’s, it would seem a little suspicious. It’s a thick slab of meat (burger-like, but seriously, it’s not a burger), with just a bit of spiciness to it.

Italian sausage: Sambetti's

Sambetti’s has been serving this sandwich up for more than 30 years, and there’s no reason to change what is pitch perfect. It’s big, it’s satisfying and it tastes like a Des Moines tradition.

What other people are saying...

No_profile_photo

rebjab43 - May 24, 2012 at 6:23 PM

I sure wish your website was user friendly trying to vote in Sandwich Smackdown not an easy task!

Report This Comment

mia1981 - May 20, 2012 at 9:52 PM

I third that, The Continental in the east village is by far one of Des Moines best restaurants. Fresh, fast and always delicious sandwiches, salads...

More...

Report This Comment
No_profile_photo

hipsterette - May 17, 2012 at 2:34 PM

I totally agree. The Blackened Tilapia sandwich from Continental is awesome. One of the hidden gems in DSM

Report This Comment
No_profile_photo

dsmdrink - May 16, 2012 at 4:28 PM

Don't know which category it fits, but I vote for the Blackened Tilapia Sandwhich from The Continental.

Report This Comment

Add a comment

Please log in to comment

 

Recent User Playlists

Btn_mknewpl_sm

More on Metromix.com